F1 - Sports

44 lapped in Brazil: Ferrari’s communication breakdown exposes another weakness in the Scuderia

Lewis Hamilton lapped in Brazil: Ferrari’s communication breakdown exposes another weakness in the Scuderia

From a remarkable opening-lap recovery to being overtaken by the race leader, Lewis Hamilton’s Brazilian Grand Prix became another difficult chapter in his Ferrari campaign. But beyond the result, the radio exchanges between Hamilton and his race engineer have raised a more uncomfortable question: did Ferrari actually know where its own driver stood in the race?

There are difficult races, there are races where strategy goes wrong, and then there are afternoons that expose problems within a team that should never be happening at the highest level of motorsport.

For Lewis Hamilton, the 2026 São Paulo Grand Prix was a combination of all three.

Hamilton crossed the finish line in ninth place, one lap behind race winner Lando Norris. On paper, he salvaged two championship points from a weekend that had already started badly. But the more interesting story emerged after the chequered flag, when previously unbroadcast radio communications revealed repeated questions from Hamilton about his position and, more concerningly, an admission from his race engineer that he did not know where the Ferrari was running.

This was not simply a case of a seven-time World Champion being unable to keep pace with the leaders. It was a race in which Ferrari struggled to give its driver the information he needed to make decisions, while Hamilton himself made a costly judgement call in the closing stages.

And that distinction matters.

### The race began with a mountain to climb

Hamilton arrived at Interlagos already compromised by Ferrari’s decision to change his internal combustion engine.

The resulting grid penalty meant he started the Grand Prix from 20th position, effectively putting him at the back of the field.

It was not an ideal starting point, particularly at a circuit where track position and changing weather can dramatically influence the outcome.

Nevertheless, Hamilton produced an impressive opening lap, gaining 11 positions and climbing to ninth.

For a moment, Ferrari had reason to believe that its driver could rescue something meaningful from an otherwise difficult weekend.

However, the early progress did not translate into sustained pace.

As the circuit began drying, Hamilton’s intermediate rear tyres deteriorated rapidly. He described the tyres as ballooning and overheating, making the car increasingly difficult to control.

He began losing ground and pushed for an early switch to slick tyres. Ferrari eventually agreed, and Hamilton became one of the first drivers to make the transition.

Initially, the decision appeared to be the correct one. The track was drying, and the slick tyres offered an opportunity to recover lost time.

But the changing conditions would create another problem later in the race.

### The turning point: Ferrari’s calls and the changing weather

The second half of the race presented a different challenge.

With approximately ten laps remaining, rain began returning to Interlagos. The track was becoming increasingly treacherous, and teams needed to decide whether to bring their drivers in for intermediate tyres.

Hamilton was running eighth and approaching Liam Lawson’s Racing Bulls.

Ferrari instructed him to enter the pits.

However, Hamilton made a different decision.

He had received information suggesting that the rain would remain relatively light. His grip on the slick tyres still felt reasonable, and he believed he was closing on Lawson.

Hamilton later explained to Sky Sports that the team had not told him that rainfall was increasing through the first sector.

His account was revealing:

The last information he received was that the rain would remain the same. When Ferrari eventually instructed him to box, he was already approaching the pit entry behind Lawson.

Lawson entered.

Hamilton stayed out.

The problem became immediately apparent when he reached Turn 1 on the following lap. The conditions were considerably wetter than he had anticipated.

He lost control of the Ferrari and spun in the slippery conditions.

By the time he recovered and entered the pits for intermediate tyres, the opportunity to preserve his position had largely disappeared.

He had effectively lost the time he had hoped to gain by remaining on slicks, while also requiring an additional pit stop.

Hamilton accepted responsibility for the decision but maintained that the information provided by Ferrari had been insufficient.

He told Sky Sports:

“If I’d have known that I would have come in.”

He also apologised to the team, acknowledging that the decision was ultimately his.

The distinction is important: Ferrari did issue the pit instruction. Hamilton chose not to follow it. However, the quality and timing of the information accompanying that instruction are now legitimate subjects of scrutiny. Sky Sports +1

### How did Ferrari lose track of its own driver’s race?

![Revealed: What Lewis Hamilton ‘San Diego’ codeword

Perhaps the most uncomfortable revelation came on November 9, when GPblog published previously unbroadcast radio exchanges between Hamilton and his race engineer, Carlo Santi.

The recordings painted a picture of a driver repeatedly asking his team for basic information about his race position.

At one point, Hamilton asked where he had fallen back to after the early exchanges. Santi informed him that he was in P13.

As the race progressed, Hamilton continued asking questions:

* What position are we?

* What position am I in?

* Where are we running?

These are not unusual questions in Formula One. Drivers frequently need clarification because pit stops, changing strategies and different tyre cycles make the apparent running order difficult to establish from the cockpit.

But the most concerning exchange came towards the closing stages.

Hamilton questioned why Norris was ahead of him. When he asked his engineer about his position, Santi initially responded that he did not know.

Hamilton’s frustration was evident.

He questioned how Norris could be ahead of him without the team being able to explain his position.

Santi subsequently clarified that they were running ninth and that Norris was ahead, with Hamilton needing to let the McLaren through.

This is where the story becomes bigger than one missed pit stop.

Ferrari is a team with extensive telemetry, live timing, race strategists and engineers monitoring every movement on the circuit. It should have access to the information necessary to establish its driver’s position.

Therefore, the suggestion that Ferrari as an organisation had no idea where Hamilton was would be an exaggeration.

What the radio recordings demonstrate is something more specific: a breakdown in the communication between Hamilton and his race engineer, with the engineer apparently unable to provide an immediate answer when asked about the running order.

That is a significant operational concern.

GPblog’s reporting also points to earlier communication problems involving the same pairing in Azerbaijan and Singapore. GPblog

### Why was Hamilton lapped by Lando Norris?

The final classification tells the story.

Lando Norris won the São Paulo Grand Prix, with Max Verstappen finishing second and Isack Hadjar completing the podium.

Hamilton finished ninth, one lap behind Norris.

It is important to understand that being lapped was not the result of one isolated incident.

Several factors contributed:

* Starting position: Hamilton began 20th following his engine-related grid penalty, leaving him with considerable ground to recover.

* Tyre degradation: His intermediate rear tyres overheated as the circuit dried, costing him early momentum.

* Additional pit stop: The changing weather and his decision to remain on slicks when Ferrari called him in resulted in a costly delay.

* Race pace: Ferrari struggled to match the leading cars, particularly McLaren and Red Bull, over the course of the afternoon.

* Lost track position: The spin and subsequent pit stop compromised his ability to recover the positions he had gained earlier.

Norris, meanwhile, had a considerably stronger afternoon. McLaren executed its strategy effectively, and Norris managed the changing conditions without making the costly mistakes that affected several competitors.

The result was a full lap between the race winner and Hamilton at the chequered flag.

Hamilton’s ninth-place finish was therefore not simply a reflection of the rain incident. It was the culmination of a difficult afternoon. Formula 1® – The Official F1® Website +1

### Ferrari’s bigger problem: communication, execution and accountability

There is an uncomfortable pattern developing around Ferrari.

The Mexican Grand Prix had already produced considerable tension between Hamilton and Charles Leclerc following their opening-lap battle and the subsequent criticism from Vasseur.

Hamilton subsequently indicated that the disagreements had been put behind them.

But Brazil offered another demonstration of how much work remains within the team.

There are three separate issues Ferrari needs to examine.

First, the race engineering relationship.

Hamilton needs accurate, timely information. His race engineer must be able to communicate tyre conditions, weather developments, relative positions and strategic opportunities without leaving the driver guessing.

Second, strategic execution.

Hamilton made the wrong call by staying out on slicks, but Ferrari also needs to examine why its warning about the worsening conditions did not reach him with sufficient clarity.

Third, internal accountability.

Ferrari cannot afford to turn every disappointing result into a discussion about individual driver mistakes. The team must examine its own processes with the same scrutiny it applies to the drivers.

The radio recordings make this particularly important.

A driver asking repeatedly where he is running is not necessarily evidence of incompetence on the pit wall. However, an engineer admitting that he does not know the position during a critical phase of the race is something that deserves an explanation.

### The verdict: Hamilton’s mistakes, but Ferrari’s questions remain

Hamilton was honest after the race. He acknowledged that his decision to remain on slick tyres was his responsibility and apologised to the mechanics and the wider Ferrari operation.

He also recognised the work the team had put into changing the engine and preparing the car.

But his comments should not bring the discussion to a close.

Ferrari needs to establish why its driver was not receiving the complete weather picture, why his race position repeatedly became a subject of confusion over the radio, and whether the working relationship between Hamilton and Carlo Santi is delivering the level of communication expected from a championship-winning operation.

The seven-time World Champion did not arrive at Ferrari to spend his afternoons asking his engineer where he was running.

And Ferrari did not bring Hamilton to Maranello simply to collect points from ninth place.

The Brazilian Grand Prix was another difficult afternoon, but the real concern is what it revealed.

Hamilton needs to make better decisions from the cockpit. Ferrari needs to make sure he has the information to make them.

Until both sides get that right, the Scuderia will continue to find itself fighting problems that have very little to do with outright speed.

.

Primary sources for publication:

* [GPblog – Hamilton’s unheard Brazil radio reveals Ferrari could not tell him where he was running](https://www.gpblog.com/en/news/hamiltons-unheard-brazil-radio-reveals-ferrari-could-not-tell-him-where-he-was-running?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

* [Sky Sports – Hamilton explains Ferrari’s lack of information](https://www.skysports.com/f1/news/13609700/lewis-hamilton-ferrari-driver-says-he-overrode-teams-pit-call-due-to-lack-of-information-provided-as-rain-fell-during-sao-paulo-gp?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

* [Formula 1 – What the teams said after the São Paulo Grand Prix](https://www.formula1.com/en/latest/article/what-the-teams-said-race-day-at-the-2026-sao-paulo-grand-prix.6WRrgNQ7FDoFnwzxR9Vjw7?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

Editorial note: The distinction between Ferrari’s overall access to live timing and the information communicated to Hamilton is important. The available radio reporting supports criticism of the driver-engineer communication, not a definitive claim that Ferrari’s entire pit wall was unaware of the race order.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *