F1 - Sports

Ferrari’s ADUO 1 Was the Better Engine — ADUO 2 Delivered More Races, Not More Performance

Ferrari’s ADUO 1 Was the Better Engine — ADUO 2 Delivered More Races, Not More Performance

The numbers tell a rather uncomfortable story for Maranello: ADUO 2 collected more points in total, but ADUO 1 produced a stronger average return. Ferrari’s second engine specification was supposed to move the Scuderia forward. Instead, it leaves a much bigger question about whether the team spent too much of the season chasing improvements that never arrived in the way they were needed.

There is a difference between introducing an upgrade and delivering an improvement. Ferrari should know that better than most. Yet, looking at the Scuderia’s 2026 campaign, the question is becoming increasingly difficult to avoid: did ADUO 2 genuinely improve Ferrari’s power unit, or did the team simply spend more time trying to extract performance from an engine that was never going to deliver what the project promised?

The comparison between Ferrari’s two ADUO specifications makes for uncomfortable reading.

Ferrari introduced its first ADUO power-unit update at the Austrian Grand Prix. The second arrived at Monza, the team’s home race. Both were intended to address shortcomings in the power unit, with the second specification representing another opportunity to close the performance deficit.

But the results do not make a convincing case for ADUO 2.

The points tell a different story

Consider Ferrari’s constructors’ points across the two periods.

From Austria through the Dutch Grand Prix, the ADUO 1 period produced:

Grand Prix| Ferrari points

Austria| 14

Britain| 51

Belgium| 30

Hungary| 22

Netherlands| 31

Total| 148

That is an average of 29.6 points per race weekend.

Now consider the period from Monza, when ADUO 2 was introduced, through Brazil:

Grand Prix| Ferrari points

Italy| 8

Spain| 12

Azerbaijan| 20

Bahrain| 27

Singapore| 39

United States| 30

Mexico| 30

Brazil| 6

Total| 172

ADUO 2 accumulated 172 points, but it did so across eight race weekends rather than five. Its average was 21.5 points per weekend.

That is a drop of approximately 27.4 per cent against the ADUO 1 period.

This is the distinction that matters. ADUO 2 has the larger cumulative total because it had three additional weekends in which to collect points. That does not make it the better-performing specification. When the comparison is normalised by the number of race weekends, ADUO 1 comes out ahead.

Of course, constructors’ points are not a laboratory measurement of engine output. They are affected by qualifying, strategy, driver performance, incidents, reliability across the entire car and the strength of the opposition. But they are the results that Ferrari actually takes home. And, on this measure, the second specification has not delivered the stronger return.

An upgrade that failed to change the picture

Ferrari’s own expectations should also be part of this discussion.

Ahead of the Austrian update, power-unit technical director Enrico Gualtieri described the development as relatively minor. He made clear that it was not expected to transform the competitive order. Charles Leclerc also warned against expecting a magic bullet.

By Monza, Fred Vasseur was again managing expectations. The second update was described as a step in the right direction, but the Scuderia was not presenting it as a solution to its underlying power deficit.

After the Italian Grand Prix, the evidence was difficult to ignore. Motorsport.com reported that Ferrari was still missing pure power, while its analysis of qualifying data highlighted a significant top-speed deficit. The second upgrade had not produced the breakthrough that the tifosi wanted to see.

Haas driver Oliver Bearman, who also received the updated Ferrari power unit at Monza, described the gain as a much smaller step than the team’s chassis improvement. His assessment was particularly telling: more power was welcome, but the engine update was not a game changer.

That is hardly the language of a technical revolution.

And if the second specification was intended to provide a meaningful step forward, Ferrari must answer a straightforward question: where was it?

Was ADUO 1 the more dependable package?

There is another argument worth making, although it needs to be made carefully.

The points comparison suggests that ADUO 1 was the more dependable competitive package across its five-race sample. Ferrari averaged almost 30 points per weekend in that period. Under ADUO 2, the average fell to 21.5.

That does not, by itself, prove that ADUO 1 suffered fewer mechanical failures. Points cannot tell us whether an individual engine had better internal durability, fewer component failures or a longer service life. Those conclusions require component-use records, failure reports and verified technical data that have not been made public.

But reliability in Formula 1 is not only about whether an engine reaches the chequered flag. It is also about whether a team can repeatedly extract the performance it expects, operate within its planned limits and turn its technical package into results.

On that broader measure, ADUO 1 has the stronger case. It gave Ferrari a better average points return. ADUO 2, despite being the newer specification, did not sustain that level.

The distinction is important: Ferrari may have improved certain characteristics of the power unit, but an improvement on a technical sheet is not automatically an improvement on the circuit.

Ferrari’s development problem is bigger than the engine

The most damaging part of this season may not be that Ferrari’s ADUO programme failed to produce a dramatic leap. It is that the team appears to have spent valuable time and resources chasing marginal gains while the wider project continued to demand attention.

Vasseur has openly acknowledged how difficult in-season engine development is. Unlike a chassis adjustment, a power-unit change involves long production lead times, expensive materials and the need to manufacture a new batch of components. He has also explained that the additional development allowance does not make the process easy or inexpensive.

There is a price to every development decision. Resources directed towards one specification cannot be spent elsewhere without consequence.

Vasseur’s comments about the choice between developing ADUO 1, ADUO 2 and the 2027 engine are particularly revealing. He has described the difficulty of running those projects in parallel and the sacrifices involved. Ferrari was not simply deciding whether to add horsepower; it was deciding where to spend finite engineering capacity and budget.

That raises an uncomfortable possibility: perhaps Ferrari should have recognised earlier that the returns from further 2026 engine development were limited, protected its resources and redirected more attention towards the next project.

There is no shame in recognising when a development direction is no longer delivering enough to justify its cost. There is, however, a serious problem if a team continues pursuing upgrades that produce only marginal gains while the season slips away.

The FIA’s assessment offers little comfort

The FIA’s ADUO findings do not provide Ferrari with a public performance figure that can settle the debate. The governing body has kept the underlying power-unit measurements confidential.

Its first review placed Ferrari more than four per cent behind the leading internal-combustion engine, granting the Scuderia two additional homologations for 2026 and two for 2027. The second review granted no further homologations to any manufacturer. On 10 November, the FIA announced that the third review had also resulted in no additional homologations, although it confirmed that the relative performance gaps had evolved.

That is not proof that ADUO 2 made Ferrari slower. Nor does it tell us which of Ferrari’s two specifications was mechanically superior. But it reinforces the fact that the upgrade programme has not produced a publicly demonstrated leap that changes Ferrari’s position.

The opportunity to develop was there. The breakthrough was not.

Ferrari needs to learn when to stop

There is a point in every development programme when persistence becomes stubbornness.

Ferrari is one of the most capable engineering organisations in motorsport. It has the facilities, the history, the technical personnel and the resources to build a championship-winning car. But reputation does not guarantee that every development decision is the right one.

The ADUO 1 versus ADUO 2 comparison should prompt some serious reflection in Maranello. The older specification delivered a stronger average points return. The newer one had more races in which to accumulate its larger total, yet its average was substantially lower. The second upgrade was publicly described as incremental, and the people closest to the programme were careful not to present it as a transformation.

Calling ADUO 2 an outright failure in mechanical terms would go beyond the evidence. Calling it a disappointing competitive return is much harder to dispute.

Ferrari cannot keep confusing development activity with progress. An engine update is not successful because it is new, because it has passed homologation, or because it produces a small gain in a controlled environment. It is successful when that gain can be used consistently, when it helps the drivers fight for better positions and when it translates into points.

By that standard, ADUO 1 has the stronger argument.

And perhaps the biggest lesson for Ferrari is not how to develop the next engine, but when to stop developing the current one. The Scuderia cannot afford to spend another season chasing improvements that promise much and deliver little. At some point, the sensible engineering decision is to stop polishing a compromised package and build something better.

For a team with Ferrari’s ambitions, this has been an expensive lesson. The tifosi do not need another explanation of how difficult engine development is. They need a power unit that delivers.

Maranello has to decide whether it wants to keep chasing marginal gains or start building a championship-winning engine. Because another season of development without meaningful results is not progress. It is time lost.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *